How to sell made-to-order merch on Shopify: order window, per-customer limits and resale

(Updated: )23 min read
How to sell made-to-order merch on Shopify: order window, per-customer limits and resale
Table of Contents

For a made-to-order merch sale, you set an order window with a start and an end, and you make only what customers order during it. You need to decide 3 things:

  • The order window (when orders open and when they close)
  • A limit per order and a limit per customer
  • When you will cancel orders you suspect are for resale

In the SellRules Shopify app, you enter the window and the limits in a made-to-order schedule. The buy button changes to “Order now” when the window opens and to “Sales ended” after the deadline. The conditions for cancelling orders go on the product page, so customers can read them before they order. This article is written by the developer of SellRules.

What customers see during the order window and after the deadline

During the window, the buy button reads “Order now”, with the estimated shipping and the limit below it. After the deadline, the button changes to a disabled “Sales ended”.

Two product pages for a birthday acrylic stand side by side. During the order window, the page shows an “Order now” button, “Est. shipping: late March” and “Limit 3 per order”. After the deadline, it shows a disabled “Sales ended” button
Two product pages for a birthday acrylic stand side by side. During the order window, the page shows an “Order now” button, “Est. shipping: late March” and “Limit 3 per order”. After the deadline, it shows a disabled “Sales ended” button

As an example, say you sell a birthday acrylic stand as made to order with these conditions (the dates and quantities are only examples):

  • The window runs from January 10 at 18:00 to January 24 at 23:59
  • Up to 3 per order
  • Ships in late March

With those conditions, here is what customers and orders do:

What the customer doesResult
Orders 2 during the windowThe order goes through. The confirmation email subject starts with “[Made to Order]”
Tries to add 4 to the cart during the windowIt isn't added to the cart, and a message explains that the limit is 3 per order
Opens the product page after midnight on January 25The page shows “Sales ended”, and the customer can't order

How made to order differs from using Shopify alone

Two product pages for the same leather card case side by side. On the left, Shopify only, the page shows “Add to cart” and “Buy it now” and no ship time. On the right, SellRules made-to-order, the page shows “Order now” with “Ships within 14 days of order” below it
Two product pages for the same leather card case side by side. On the left, Shopify only, the page shows “Add to cart” and “Buy it now” and no ship time. On the right, SellRules made-to-order, the page shows “Order now” with “Ships within 14 days of order” below it

Shopify alone can take orders at 0 inventory if you turn on “Continue selling when out of stock” in the product's inventory settings. But you have to switch the settings by hand when the window opens and when it closes.

TaskShopify aloneSellRules
Start and end of the order windowPublish and unpublish the product in the admin at those timesThe buy button switches at the date and time you enter
Limit per orderOne number for every productSet per product
Limit per customer across ordersCan't be set (customers can split their purchase into separate orders)“Cumulative quantity limit per customer” stops them
Holding shipment until you've made the itemPut each order on hold by handShipment is held automatically when the order comes in

Shopify also has a built-in setting that caps how many of an item can go in one cart (Shopify Help, checked November 14, 2026). That cap applies to every product in the store with the same number, and it doesn't count repeat purchases split across orders.

Set the order window to the exact time it starts and ends

Set the window to start and end at exact times. That way, everyone who comes from your announcement can order at the same moment.

Work out the deadline backwards from the estimated ship date. If you use a factory, you count the orders after the deadline and then place your order. Add the days from order to delivery to the days for inspection and shipping once the goods arrive, and pick a deadline that still meets the ship date. If the goods need to arrive before an event, count back from the event date. For example, if delivery takes 5 weeks after you order and inspection and shipping take 1 week, the deadline is 6 weeks before the event.

Also put the deadline and ship date in the product description.

Order window: January 10, 18:00 to January 24, 23:59 Estimated shipping: late March We make exactly as many as are ordered during the order window. We can't accept orders after the window closes.

Since you make everything ordered during the window, you normally take orders without a total quantity limit. Set a “Total quantity limit” only for products where the factory's capacity or your materials are limited.

Set a limit per order and a limit per customer

Choose the limit that matches the kind of buying you want to stop.

Kind of buying to stopSellRules settingLimit customers see
Buying a lot in one order“Max per order”“Limit 3 per order”
Splitting purchases across several orders“Cumulative quantity limit per customer” and “Login required”“Limit 1 per customer in total”

A made-to-order sale reaches everyone who orders during the window, so for most merch a per-order limit is enough. For products that one person might buy many of, such as blind-box pin badges, set the limit higher.

For something like a signed postcard, where the number you can make is fixed, limit the total per customer instead. “Cumulative quantity limit per customer” adds up the orders of a logged-in customer, so set purchase eligibility to “Login required”. Guest orders can't be matched to one person, so they can't be counted.

To sell only to fan club members, set purchase eligibility to “Tag required” and tag the members' customer accounts. For how to add tags, see how to run a members-only sale.

Write down how you handle suspected resale before orders open

Purchase limits count orders from the same customer account, so an order from a different account counts as a different customer. Whether to cancel such orders is up to you, so state your conditions on the product page before the window opens.

If we find orders placed for resale, or orders over the limit, after the order window, we will cancel them before production.

In a made-to-order sale, the time between the deadline and the start of production is when you can compare orders. Made-to-order orders appear in SellRules “Order progress” as “Not started”, and shipment stays on hold until you click “Start production”. Compare customer names there, check the shipping address on the Shopify order page for any order that looks off, and then cancel it. Place your order with the factory using the number of orders that remain.

For how to recognize orders from different accounts, “Coming soon” to block orders before launch, and selling only to customers who win a draw, see how to reduce resale and bulk buying of limited items.

How to set it up in SellRules

You set the order window and the limits in one made-to-order schedule.

The SellRules made-to-order creation screen. “Order start date” is January 10, 2027 at 18:00, “End sales and show “Sales ended”” is selected under “When made-to-order ends”, and “Date sales end” is January 25, 2027
The SellRules made-to-order creation screen. “Order start date” is January 10, 2027 at 18:00, “End sales and show “Sales ended”” is selected under “When made-to-order ends”, and “Date sales end” is January 25, 2027

  1. In Shopify, go to “Online Store” → “Themes” → “Customize”, turn on SellRules under “App embeds” on the left, and save.
  2. In SellRules, open the “Made to order” tab under “Sales schedules”, click “Create made to order”, and choose your merch product with “Select product”.
  3. Under “Order start date”, enter the date and time the window opens (January 10, 18:00).
  4. Under “When made-to-order ends”, choose “End sales and show "Sales ended"”, and under “Date sales end” enter the day after your deadline (January 25). The product shows “Sales ended” from 0:00 that day.
  5. Under “How to set the shipping date”, choose “Ship on fixed date”, enter “late March” in “Estimated shipping (text)”, and enter a date you can keep in “Estimated ship date”.
  6. Click “Show extra settings” and enter 3 under “Max per order” in “Purchase limits (optional)”. For a product limited by the total per customer, also fill in “Cumulative quantity limit per customer” and choose “Login required” for purchase eligibility.
  7. Click “Create”.

The “Purchase limits (optional)” section in SellRules. “Max per order” is set to 3, with the “Max per customer (cumulative)” field below it
The “Purchase limits (optional)” section in SellRules. “Max per order” is set to 3, with the “Max per customer (cumulative)” field below it

For a product with a limit, also check in Shopify under “Settings” → “Checkout” → “Checkout rules” that “Purchase limits (SellRules)” is turned on.

For each made-to-order screen and how to check it with a test order, see how to sell made-to-order products on Shopify.

What to do after the deadline

After the deadline, check how many orders you have, place your order, and ship when the goods arrive.

  1. In SellRules, open the “Made to order” tab under “Sales schedules” and look at “Orders” for that product.
  2. In “Order progress”, compare the orders listed as “Not started”. For any you will cancel, check the shipping address on the Shopify order page and cancel there.
  3. Place your order with the factory using the number of orders that remain.
  4. When you are ready to prepare shipment, click “Start production” on the order in “Order progress” to release the hold. To release several at once, select the orders and click “Start production / prepare shipment”.

If you find you will miss the ship date, click “Edit ship date” in “Order progress”, enter the new date, select “Notify customer of delay” and save.

When it doesn't work

ProblemCauseFix
The regular buy button is still showing after the start timeThe SellRules app embed is off in the live themeTurn it on and save, as in step 1
“Sales ended” appeared on the morning of the deadline dayYou entered the deadline day itself in “Date sales end”Enter the day after the deadline
An order over the limit got through checkout“Purchase limits (SellRules)” is not turned onTurn it on in “Checkout rules”
A guest order went over the cumulative limitPurchase eligibility is “No restriction”Set purchase eligibility to “Login required”

Pricing

Made to order and purchase limits work on the Free plan. The Free plan covers a lifetime total of 10 pre-orders and made-to-order orders. That is enough to try the window switch and the limits on your first merch product.

When you want to take more than 10 orders on the Free plan, switch to the Launch plan (US$7.99 per month).

SellRules plans and pricing

Monthly priceLaunchEvery feature includedFreeStart with one product
Monthly priceUS$7.99 per monthFree
Free trial10 daysNone
Pre-order and made-to-order ordersUnlimitedUp to 10 in total
Back-in-stock and sale-start emails (Notify Me)UnlimitedUp to 15 in total (not refilled monthly)
Purchase limitsNo limit on productsUp to 1 product
Customizable notification emailsYesNo
Deposit paymentsYesNo

Pre-orders, made-to-order, back-in-stock alerts, purchase limits, stockout switching, deposit payments and order processing are all included in the Launch plan.

The first 10 days of the Launch plan are free. If you remove the app during the trial, you are not charged.

On the Launch plan, back-in-stock and sale-start emails have no sending cap. Required messages such as order confirmations, shipping updates and balance reminders are sent on every plan regardless of the cap.

The Standard and Pro plans are closed to new sign-ups. Shops already on them keep their current terms.

You can install SellRules from the Shopify App Store, where the pricing and trial terms are also listed.

Frequently asked questions

Can I extend the order window for customers who missed the deadline?

Yes. Open the product in “Sales schedules” in SellRules, change “Date sales end” to a new date and save. The product page goes back to “Order now”. If you have already placed your order with the manufacturer, it is easier to count the extra orders as a separate order window.

What happens if a customer orders a made-to-order product together with an in-stock product?

It is accepted as one order. The cart shows “Your cart contains items with different estimated ship dates. Consider checking out separately if you need items sooner.”, and shipment of the made-to-order item stays on hold until you click “Start production”.

Related articles:

The acrylic stand, dates and quantities are examples for illustration.

Related Articles